City of Portola approves feasibility draft after LESSG presentation
Lauren Westmoreland
[email protected]
The long-awaited Local Emergency Services Study Group (LESSG) draft feasibility study on the formation of a new fire district in Eastern Plumas county was reported on at a recent meeting of City of Portola council meeting with a presentation given Mayor Pro Tem Tom Cooley.
Eastern Plumas County is served by a number of small fire protection agencies that have been established over time to provide fire and emergency response services to communities.
Over the past decade, the rising costs of equipment, increase in severe wildfires, and decline of volunteers has made it more and more difficult to provide services in many rural areas including those located in Eastern Plumas County. Continued growth and scattered residential development also has resulted in dispersed areas that demand services but are currently outside of any local jurisdiction that is responsible for providing fire services.
Local fire agencies often respond to calls in these non-jurisdictional “no-man’s-land” areas but do not receive property tax or other consistent and reliable revenue to support the service.
Due to these circumstances, the agencies in this region have come together to research and identify the best course of action to ensure the safety of all communities through adequate and sustainable provision of emergency response services.
Background
“The study that was done by the Plumas County Civil Grand Jury recommended that the city along with other area agencies look at the possibility of reorganization of services,” Cooley said. “Then, in January 2020, a Local Emergency Services Study Group (LESSG) was created to explore ways to strengthen and improve the provision of fire and emergency services throughout the region.”
The LESSG is comprised of representatives from each participating agency, which include Beckwourth Fire Protection District, Gold Mountain Community Services District, Sierra Valley Fire Protection District, and the City of Portola.
After collecting extensive information on the status of the existing districts and ‘robust discussion with stakeholders’, the LESSG recommended that the best course of action was to form a new fire protection district that would consolidate services in the region.
The LESSG feasibility study states that the proposed formation will officially merge the operations of four different agencies currently providing fire services into one efficient, effective, and sustainable emergency services system. “This will provide a proactive, sustainable solution for future fire and emergency service needs for the area by creating a regional district with an improved economy of scale and associated benefits,” the study states.
Cooley commented, “This Plan for Service details establishment of the new fire district, including how services will be provided upon formation and how services will be funded.”
Current challenges
Cooley gave an overview of the reported challenges faced by Eastern Plumas fire districts as they currently stand, as presented in the study.
Major challenges included aging infrastructure and equipment, an increased demand for services, difficulties recruiting and retaining volunteers, a lack of daytime staffing, and a strain on existing agencies, with many calls served outside of any established fire district.
Other challenges discussed included underserved residents, with approximately 15 percent of the estimated population within the new fire district currently falling outside of established fire districts with no guarantee of structural fire and EMS protection.
Irregular boundaries were also mentioned, combined with the number of fire providers in a small area, which contributes to challenges in coordination, consistency in training and response, and planning.
“The region is consequently plagued by a disjointed service delivery structure that lends itself to duplication of efforts and expenses,” Cooley noted.
Insufficient funding was stated as a challenge, with funding being described as “fractured” and supported by a combination of inequitable property tax sharing, special taxes, and local fundraising opportunities.
Property tax sharing is based on 1975 models, while the new fire district would be funded by a combination of property taxes and a new special tax that would be levied consistently through the district. The taxes would be based on land use types provided by the Plumas County Assessors’ Office.
Lastly, board vacancies were discussed as a challenge, with all districts seeming to face a lack of public interest with little to no attendance at board meetings, along with board vacancies and uncontested elections. It is thought that a single new leadership body overseeing fire protection services in the region would better sustain participation and engagement within the community.
For more on each participating agency, further information can be found in the Eastern Plumas Fire Municipal Service Review prepared by Plumas LAFCo at www.plumaslafco.org/msrs-and-soi-updates .
Proposed formation of a new fire district
The new fire district is proposed to be formed under the Fire District Law of 1987 in order to provide fire protection services, rescue services, emergency medical services, hazardous material emergency response services, and other services relating to the protection of lives and property.
The new 468-square-mile proposed district will be governed by a five-member board of directors initially elected at-large from within the district by registered voters residing within the boundaries of the district.
Directors will serve staggered four-year terms, with two directors initially being elected for a two-year term. As a special district, the new fire district would be supported by revenue from a combination of taxes, fees, grants, and fundraising.
Formation of the new fire district will be contingent upon establishment of a special tax and successful negotiation of a property tax exchange agreement with Plumas County.
If approved, the special tax will be included on property owners’ annual property tax bill distributed by the county. Although these taxes are collected by the county, they would not go to the state like property taxes. Instead, they will be deposited in a fund for the sole use of the new fire district.
The new fire district recognizes the proposed special tax may create a burden for low-income property owners in the region. For this reason, the new district will establish procedures for implementing a Low-Income Exemption, to allow landowners who fall within the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) income limits for “very low” or “poverty level” to apply for a partial or complete exemption from the tax.
To ensure that the proposed special tax will retain its purchasing power in future years, it is proposed to include an inflationary clause which will allow the new fire district board, to adjust the tax, if needed, by no more than the cost of living as measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI) for the preceding year as prepared by the United States Bureau of Labor. This increase will not exceed 3 percent and must be approved by resolution at a properly noticed public hearing.
Combined, these revenue sources could provide up to $600,000 in annual revenue to the support the proposed new district. This would allow the district to hire dedicated full-time and part-time emergency responders in addition to administrative support staff.
It will also allow the district to provide the necessary training for staff and volunteers, purchase and maintain equipment, and improve and expand fire stations in the region, according to the draft.
A tax exchange agreement was also discussed, and in addition to proposing the new special tax, the new fire district will work with the county to receive a portion of property taxes that are already being collected. If negotiations are successful, the agreement would be approved by the Plumas County Board of Supervisors and could initially generate an estimated $200,000 per year, with potential to grow based on increases in property value in the district.
This agreement would be a transfer of monies already paid by the county to the existing agencies, and there would be no additional cost to property owners or loss of revenue to the county.

District dissolutions and divestitures
At the same time of the proposed formation of the new fire district, both Beckwourth and Sierra Valley fire protection districts would be dissolved, and all assets belonging to those districts would then be transferred to the new fire district. Upon dissolution, all existing special taxes and assessments used to fund community fire protection and rescue services will terminate and the new voter-approved special tax would be levied in their place.
Should the new district be unsuccessful in establishing a new special tax and/or negotiating a tax exchange agreement with Plumas County or otherwise fail to meet the conditions of approval for formation of the district, then the Beckwourth and Sierra Valley FPDs will not be dissolved.
Each department will retain their assets and powers to provide fire and emergency response services, and any special taxes and assessments for the districts will continued to be levied.
Also concurrent with the proposed formation of the new fire district, the Gold Mountain CSD will proceed with a divestiture of power to provide fire protection, and the City of Portola will transfer responsibility for providing fire protection to the new fire district.
Gold Mountain CSD will maintain its powers to provide wildland fire response and hazardous fuels reduction and will continue to levy a reduced special tax to support these services. The City of Portola will transfer all responsibility and assets related to fire protection services to the new fire district.
In the event the formation of the new fire district fails, Gold Mountain CSD and the City of Portola will retain their powers to provide community fire protection and emergency response and continue to levy all associated special taxes, assessments, and fees.
After the presentation was given, the City of Portola council discussed the next steps and how to get the engagement of the community.
“We want everyone to be as accurately informed as possible when it comes time to vote. We will be engaging the public in naming the new district as well,” Cooley noted.
Interim City Manager Jon Kennedy shared his enthusiasm for the efforts of the LESSG, stating that this was an emotional issue for everyone, and that this was the first time he had seen such an intellectual, comprehensive assessment of the needs of the fire departments on this end of the county.
“I think this is by far the greatest advancement I have ever seen in the county towards solving this problem,” Kennedy said.
A motion was made to approve the draft feasibility study so that the LESSG can proceed in the next stage, an application to LAFCo.
The entire draft can be found online here.
